Rising mortgage rates impact on the housing market overstated: BuyersBuyers

Mortgage rates will rise gradually over the next couple of years, according to Pete Wargent, co-founder of BuyersBuyers. But the impact on the housing market won’t be too dramatic, Wargent said. Doron Peleg, co-founder and CEO of BuyersBuyers, said financial markets are pricing interest rate hikes aggressively, "but it’s unlikely we’ll see a significant move in the cash rate any time soon." “Even if the cash rate does increase in time, we think that any increases will be delivered gradually, and in a controlled manner,” Pelog said. “The Reserve Bank may not be in too much a rush to hike rates, though, given that annual wages growth is only 2.2 per cent, and expectations for pay rises are still anchored at low levels. “Fiscal support will also be wound back over the next year or two, and it’s not yet clear how the economy will track when this very large fiscal support is withdrawn. “In any case, much of the inflation relates to supply chain issues in 2021, which will be mostly resolved later in 2022, particularly for food and new dwelling costs, so hiking interest rates significantly while real wages are negative might not be desirable” Mr Peleg said. Their commentary comes as economists including from the Commonwealth Bank, Westpac and AMP Capital expect an August rate rise. AMP Capital's chief economist Shane Oliver says any earlier rate increase would bring forward the peak in property prices. HSBC chief economist for Australia and New Zealand, Paul Bloxham still expects the first rate rise to be in 2023, while forecasting single-digit house price growth in 2022, but no declines. Wargent of BuyersBuyers said compared to some of the inflation readings coming out of Europe or the U.S. – and even New Zealand - "inflation is not exactly running out of control in Australia. “In fact, inflation has largely been driven by food and new dwelling costs, where pressure will likely ease in 2022, and fuel costs, which are admittedly less predictable”. He added commentators have sometimes overstated the impact of rising mortgage rates on the Australian housing market for four main reasons. “Firstly, because inflation is exogenous to housing market modelling, estimates of the impact on housing prices should be based upon changes in real interest rates. "If inflation expectations are to move materially higher, then any related impact on housing prices would correspondingly be lessened. "Given Reserve Bank modelling was referenced in 2019 to isolate the impact of lower real rates, it doesn’t make sense to translate estimates across to forecasts today, given that the context is not the same”. “Secondly, the response of prices in the housing market model is non-linear, so logically interest rate cuts should have had a far greater positive impact on sentiment as interest rates approached zero.” “Thirdly, any impact on housing prices should be relative to your baseline forecasts. Thus, if forecasts were for housing prices to increase by, say, a few per cent per annum, then only relative to these forecasts would the impact on prices be seen as a result of rising mortgage rates.” “And fourthly, any dramatic predictions of a crunch would need to assume no other change in macro variables, which is unrealistic. In reality, in our opinion, we should be expecting employment growth and population growth to come roaring back over the next couple of years, comfortably offsetting even a potential 1 per cent increase in interest rates”. “And, as noted, we also expect hikes to the cash rate to be delivered in a considered and gradual manner, even if funding costs are rising.” “We have consistently discussed many of these variables with our clients such as employment growth, the immigration reboot, fierce competition between lenders, low out-of-pocket expenses for property investors, and the ability of households to absorb higher repayments” Wargent said. “We think mortgage rates will rise in 2022 and 2023, but the impact of this on the housing market has often been overstated.”