56 posts in this thread / 0 new
Last post

Pages

CBD | Hotel Lindrum | 26-30 Flinders Street | 100m | 30L | Mixed Use

Mark Baljak's picture
#1

Worthy of its own thread

Design by Bates Smart

Demo plan

Old and new designs

Sections

Ground floor

Stacker system

Renders

Back to top
Aussie Steve's picture
#2

This look ok to me, but I would be keen to know how the eastern wall will be treated and if there is a blank wall towards the old Shell House or windows of some sort.

Back to top
3000's picture
#3

Looks like there may be a blank wall next to shell house. The other side has me worried, no render of that side usually says "insert blank wall here"

Back to top
theboynoodle's picture
#4

I'm confused.

One side is right up against Shell House, so obviously it is blank and that must be OK, yes?

The other (long) side is depicted in the renders. The only thing missing from the renders is the 'back', but that has balconies on it so that can't be blank.

So there's one blank wall.. and that's the one that's right up against the neighbor.. so it wouldn't be anything else.

What am I missing?

Back to top
3000's picture
#5

My mistake. Your are correct, next to shell house has a blank wall.

Back to top
Riddlz's picture
#6

Original taller version

Back to top
Riddlz's picture
#7

Back to top
3000's picture
#8

I may catch some fire here (q man incoming) but I prefer the shorter version.

Back to top
Mark Baljak's picture
#9

I'd say the taller one looks more elegant. but hey...

Back to top
Michael Berquez's picture
#10

Regardless, it's still a really nice looking tower

Back to top
Primal Beauty's picture
#11

I think I prefer a shorter one in this location...it slots nicely between the two buildings without sticking out too much or not at all in this case...good decision!

Back to top
Peter Maltezos's picture
#12

http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/tower-plan-for-melbournes-hotel-lindru...

Tower plan for Melbourne's Hotel Lindrum

SEPTEMBER 1 2016 - 7:11PM Aisha Dow

The heritage-listed luxury Hotel Lindrum on Flinders Street is about to get a new 100-metre tower.

Melbourne City Council is likely to sign off on the project next week, which would see the back 30 metres of the existing building demolished to make way for a modern addition.

Originally the owners of the hotel had asked to build a much larger skyscraper of 183 metres, but amended their application in April for the prime CBD site.

As well as 77 hotel rooms, the 30-storey redevelopment will include 62 residential apartments.

Council officers have recommended Melbourne councillors grant a permit for the project, finding the design would not detract from the neighbouring Shell House at 1 Spring Street, designed by prominent Australian architect Harry Seidler.

I collect, therefore I am. thecollectormm.com.au
Back to top
Grampians's picture
#13

bs
it was never going to "detract from Shell House" in fact potentially cover up it's butt ugly wall. In any case, what frickin business does the planning authority have in "protecting Shell House." To me this is fishy and I suspect political business arm was used to also protect the tall Collins St towers much vaunted views (ahem insider deals). I think that this is a warm up for Wynne to completely slash the incredible proposal for next door.

Back to top
Michael Berquez's picture
#14

Yep....."detract from shell house"?????? How about considering that this would've helped cover up what many of us see as a blight on our skyline.

Back to top
Bilby's picture
#15

The planning authority will be concerned about the potential heritage significance of Seidler's most impressive 1980s Melbourne tower. On the other hand, t's a long bow to draw arguing that anyone would be concerned about protecting views in Melbourne - where is the evidence for this anywhere else in the city over the last 5 years?

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/victoria/harry-seidlerdesigned-shell-ho...

Back to top
Michael Berquez's picture
#16

Whoever said the Seidler tower was "impressive"?

Back to top
Riddlz's picture
#17

It certainly ranks among his worst tower designs and that's saying something considering that most of his high-rises are of low architectural value and quality.

Back to top
Michael Berquez's picture
#18

True, he butchered Brisbane's skyline (fortunately Brisbane's skyline focus has shifted recently)...and Melbourne CBD's entire right hand corner is almost entirely ruined by this beast.

Back to top
Dean's picture
#19

You guys shouldn't be too hard on Shell House. I think its blank walls are both epic and intimate at the same time... :)

Back to top
Melbourne_Fragments's picture
#20

your'e being both sardonic and insulting but also correct Dean ;)

Back to top
Dean's picture
#21

He deserves it.

Back to top
Melbourne_Fragments's picture
#22

ive seen him contribute much more to this forum than you Dean, literally all you do here is shout at people and add no new observations. you are correct about Shell house being both epic yet intimate in it's choice or materials though

Back to top
Dean's picture
#23

Move on champ. I don't need to be lectured to by lightweights.

Back to top
3000's picture
#24

To be fair, you started this. Sure can dish it out....

Back to top
Melbourne_Fragments's picture
#25

lol it's an urbanism forum not an amateur boxing gym

Back to top
Primal Beauty's picture
#26

Few punches here and there makes it more exciting!
There is nothing better than a good bitch fight amongst presumably two guys!
Go girls!!!

Back to top

Pages