Foreign buyer crackdown is no witch hunt says Joe Hockey after Point Piper FIRB divestiture order

Foreign buyer crackdown is no witch hunt says Joe Hockey after Point Piper FIRB divestiture order
Jonathan ChancellorDecember 7, 2020

While accountants PwC brush up on Point Piper foreign buyer laws, the Federal Treasurer Joe Hockey says further suspicious house purchases across Australia were to be investigated by the reinvigorated Foreign Investment Review Board (FIRB).

It follows the government decision to force the sale of the $39 million Point Piper trophy home, Villa de Mare (pictured above).

"It's amazing how many phone calls we got this morning," a chuffed Joe Hockey said yesterday, ignoring the backlash from some business interests which sees far wider ramifications for Chinese trade relations.

"We're not going on a witch hunt," the Treasurer added.

"And we definitely don't want an atmosphere of xenophobia or anything.

"We actually just want to be in a position where we maintain, preserve and enhance the integrity of the foreign investment regime."

The Sydney-based, but beneficially China-owned, company Golden Fast Foods has 90 days to offload 63-67 Wolseley Road, Point Piper after being found to have breached foreign investment rules.

The company was deemed ultimately beneficially controlled by Chinese developer Evergrande Real Estate Group and China's 15th richest man, according to Forbes, Xu Jiayin.

Golden Fast Foods is directed by Sydney-based accountant and former PwC partner Stanley Brogan and two Chinese associates, including the Evergrande director Huang Xiangui, as Property Observer noted on its November 2014 settlement.

The federal goverrnment forced sale comes as Xu shortly attends, as a delegate, China's annual parliamentary meeting, the main public event on China's political calendar.

Searches on Baidu, a Chinese version of Google, brought up the matter of Xu's Point Piper mansion, though with an error page saying "the news content was unable to be provided".

Earlier critical coments by internet users had appeared on the Weibo website, according to The Australian's China correspondent, Scott Murdoch.

Hockey would give no details of the other houses under suspicion but advised they were across price ranges.

The Australian Financial Review reported Joe Hockey had indicated he had no sympathy for the owner of the home and the FIRB investigation had been requested personally.

The sale of Villa del Mare is FIRB's first forced divestment since 2006 coincided with the unveiling of a federal government consultation paper.

The proposed measures are designed to restore confidence in a foreign investment review system that had not prosecuted anyone for breaching the rules in nine years.

"We welcome foreign investment. It is hugely important," Hockey said.

But Sydney's top end of town fears the fallout will be much wider than a prestige property upheaval, arguing it was easy for the Chinese government to tacitly advise banks that there were not to be acquisitions of Australian businesses for a while.

Geoff Raby, Australia's former ambassador to Beijing, recently noted Chinese interest in Australian farms and processing assets was surging.

Since 1 March, foreign investors require approval from the FIRB to buy agricultural land worth $15 million, down from the previous threshold of $252 million.

Raby, who was the Chinese ambassador from 2007-2011 and has since founded Beijing-based advisory Geoff Raby & Associates, said the changes had been noticed in China.

"The Chinese certainly wonder what our intention is and ask: Is this directed against China? Is this a Chinese concern we have? Any change in the [regulatory] regime will create uncertainty," he told The Australian Financial Review following his presentation to the ABARES Outlook 2015 conference in Canberra.

The Australian reported PwC had no role during the purchase of the Point Piper property as PwC merely helped Mr Xu establish the shelf company that later bought the property.

The firm was also called in for advice after questions arose about why approval for the transaction had not been sought by the FIRB, The Australian advised.

 

 

 

Jonathan Chancellor

Jonathan Chancellor is one of Australia's most respected property journalists, having been at the top of the game since the early 1980s. Jonathan co-founded the property industry website Property Observer and has written for national and international publications.

Editor's Picks