Were the Jolie-Pitts correct to rent Vaucluse's Villa Igiea? He Said/She Said

Villa Igiea, best remembered as the long-time Vaucluse home of the late TNT transport tycoon Sir Peter Abeles and his late widow, Lady (Kitty) Abeles, was the surprise choice as the Sydney base of Hollywood star Angelina Jolie and her six children, with Brad Pitt also flying in to spend time with the family. Jolie is here in Australia to shoot the World War II drama Unbroken over three or so months.

Our commentators Jonathan Chancellor and Margie Blok differ on whether the Jolie-Pitts were correct in selecting Vaucluse's Villa Igiea as their Sydney base?

HE SAID: YES

Indeed Angelina was quite right, for she gets a magnificent European style villa with picture perfect postcard views gunbarreling across the harbour to the Harbour Bridge and Opera House. It is one of the most delightful family homes I've been inside.

Inspired by a grand 1908 villa in Palermo, Sicily, Villa Igiea dates back to the 1920s when it was built by the retailing Grace family to a design by Neville Hampson, the architect who designed Boomerang, the grand Spanish Mission style harbourfront mansion at Elizabeth Bay.

But Villa Igiea was built with its then Vaucluse Road, Vaucluse address in the Riviera Liberty style, featuring strong Italianate art nouveau influences before getting a quick refreshing update during the McWilliam family’s ownership during the early 2000s and then under the current Burt family ownership a total contemporary refurbishment worthy of a Vogue spread. (pictured below).

{yoogallery src=[images/stories/2013/12/17/vau]}

The imposing mansion was bought in 1970 by Sir Peter Abeles who paid $450,000 for the Queens Avenue property. It was known then as the Aegean Villa, sold by meat exporter and onetime Hellenic Club president, Steve Varvaressos, and described by my early 1980s SMH property editor predecessor John Rich as among the best houses in Sydney.

And during the next three decades, the five-bedroom, three storey white-washed sandstone residence, with its panoramic Harbour Bridge views, was often host to royalty and prime ministers.

After Sir Peter Abeles died in mid-1999, his widow, Lady (Kitty) Abeles, put a $20 million asking price on the property, which I recall briefly attracted potential buying interest from then Hollywood royalty, the actors Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman, before their separation.

Rightly billed as one of Australia's most impressive properties, Villa Igiea stands in 2,160 square metre grounds high above Hermit Bay. There's also the additional adjacent 800 square metres holding.

All set behind remote-controlled gates on the Queens Avenue cul-de-sac, the house is surrounded by balustraded terraces and sprawling manicured gardens with pool, along with underground garaging installed during its recent works project.

It was Vaucluse’s priciest sale when in 2005 Villa Igiea sold to Wayne Burt, a London-based entrepreneurial expat, for close to $17.3 million. Burt, who spent $4.9 million on the neighbouring house in 2009, has extensive international experiences in investment banking in Sydney, London and Monaco including some years at Macquarie Bank, Deutsche Bank and Bain Capital.

The price well and truly beat the previous suburb record of a Coolong Road waterfront mansion sold by retired bookmaker Bob Bland for $14,725,000 in 2002 to the Walton clan who engaged Luigi Rosselli to design a new house which was briefly rented by Leonardo di Caprio when he was filming the Great Gastby in 2012.

People like Vaucluse for its harbourfront beaches and parklands at Nielsen Park and Parsley Bay. It also has easy access to the harbour and the walking tracks on The Hermitage or near Macquarie Lighthouse.

A prestigious suburb with large houses, many with striking harbour views, Vaucluse attracts families for its leafy environs, relaxed lifestyle and close proximity to private schools. Easy access to parks, playgrounds and beaches suited to small children are the motivating factors for families moving to the area – including the Jolie-Pitts.

Of course Point Piper's Altona ruled the rental roost until its $52 million sale earlier this year. With Villa Igiea new to the prestige executive rental pool, its rental price remains undisclosed, disallowing any price comparison.

SHE SAID: NO

I think Barford, the seven-bedroom Georgian style mansion at Bellevue Hill (pictured below) would have been a better choice for the Hollywood power couple for it is exceptionally private estate which could be especially handy for celebrity renters when pesky paparazzi are stalking.

As well as being hidden from street view, Barford has two entrances (one on Victoria Road and another on Rupertswood Avenue), so comings and goings in cars with dark-tinted windows would ensure a degree of privacy as well as safety.

In my view, celebrity renters are better off choosing Bellevue Hill over Vaucluse, for Bellevue Hill is just four kilometres from the city, as well as being very close to Double Bay, Bondi Junction and the harbour.

{yoogallery src=[images/stories/2013/12/11/bell]}

Sydneysiders would be aware that Vaucluse property tends to go in and out of fashion, although expats may not understand that Vaucluse’s travel distance puts the suburb out of favour with many locals.

One of Bellevue Hill’s most prestigious properties, the Barford estate, was promoted for lease only this week at a weekly rental of $25,000 through Run Property agent, Kyara Coakes for its Hawaiian-based owner, Ian Joye.

But Barford has long been a preferred rental property for celebrities seeking a luxury mansion with privacy.

In 2001 actor Will Smith led the march to lease Barford. He reportedly paid $4,000 a week during the time he was here to support his wife Jada Pinkett-Smith who was in Sydney to work on the movie, Matrix 2.

Altona was his harbourfront preference, but the pop star Bono has been among the more recent renters – in 2010 he reputedly paid the advertised price of $40,000 a week for the Bellevue Hill property.

Run Property’s internet advertisements claim Barford “as one of the country's most significant private holdings and one of the finest homes in Australia”.

The ads state Barford is "the best Sydney has to offer in location and timeless design. It offers sweeping views across Rose Bay, Sydney Harbour and beyond the Heads of Manly, yet affords total privacy. There is no opportunity for paparazzi to moor outside Barford.”

Named after a village beside the River Leam in Warwickshire, England, Barford was built in 1931 for media tycoon Sir Warwick Fairfax who resided there until the late 1960s when he sold it to former Melbourne car salesman, Emmanuel Margolin.

In 1980 Margolin sold Barford for around $1.5 million to property traders, Maurice Bernhardt (a former Double Bay estate agent) and Max Franks.

Not long after Bernhardt and Franks sold Barford to Barry and Wendy Loiterton who operated the tourist-marketing business, Leisuremark.

Of course, in 1985, Barford’s magnificent garden was the setting for a French champagne and lobster feast attended by a 500-strong glitterari set to celebrate the wedding of socialite Glen-Marie North to Liberal Party stalwart Bob Frost.

I recall Barford’s last sale in late 1986 for $9,875,000 to the entrepreneurial accountant Ian Joye. This deal was headline news for it was near enough Sydney’s first $10 million sale with Jonathan breaking the story in January 1987 in his much remembered back page Today's People, SMH column.

Ian Joye certainly knows select properties.

Properties on the northern side of Sydney rarely attract celebrity renters or command high prices – with the exception of Palm Beach’s Kalua, a 5,500 square metre landmark beachfront estate which Ian Joye sold for $22 million in 2012.

Only popular during the summer season, Kalua was rented over the years by the likes of Elle Macpherson, Nicole Kidman, John Cleese and Rupert Murdoch reputedly at $25,000 or so a week, although Palm Beach rentals tend to ebb like high and low tides.

Elsewhere across Sydney I recall then record rentals including $16,000 a week for Musgrave House in Mosman rented by Diana Ross during her 1989 tour and $25,000 a week paid by singer Paul McCartney in 1993 for a Mosman, waterfront on Wyargine Point.