Subdued business investment, healthy home prices: CommSec's Savanth Sebastian

Subdued business investment, healthy home prices: CommSec's Savanth Sebastian
Jonathan ChancellorFebruary 6, 2021
GUEST OBSERVER 
 
If you just looked at the top level results, there wasn’t a lot of good news in the business investment report.
 
Spending recorded a sizable quarterly fall, expectations of future investment are down over 14 percent compared with a year ago and the weakness was across all the states and territories bar Victoria and Queensland.
 
But this is really backward looking, categorising an environment that included the lead up to the Federal Election and Brexit – hardly an environment that would see businesses lift investment plans.
 
 

However the main good news or rather glimmer of hope was the lift in expected investment plans compared with last quarter. The fourth estimate for 2016/17 is $106.9 billion, up 1.7 per cent on the third estimate (June quarter). In addition investment plans have lifted substantially in the past six months, up by 17 percent.

Encouragingly the lift in investment plans over the last couple of quarters, may be a sign of a shift in momentum by the business sector, but it is too early to tell. Certainly the lift in business conditions in recent months may be supportive of a lift in investment plans – especially in light of the surge in commodity prices and improvement in the global economy. No doubt the rebalancing across the economy is also being supported by the slide in the Australian dollar – an outcome that should garner further traction in coming quarters. But as we have seen in the past, business may plan for future investment but then mothball projects if the economic landscape doesn’t improve.

Click to enlarge

Business spending looks like continuing to be a weight on Australia’s economic growth performance in the medium term. The Reserve Bank could cut rates again, but it is far from certain that this would have a measurable impact in further lifting business spending. The Reserve Bank is more forward- looking and is likely to maintain its neutral bias on a more upbeat medium term growth outlook.
 
It may be no surprise to see that home prices continue to lift across most capital cities. But what was clearly surprising was the slide in apartment prices across the nation, in particular the outsized 3.2 per cent fall in Melbourne apartment prices. Over the last year there has been a lot of discussion on the anticipated lift in housing supply, with particular concern on inner city Melbourne and Brisbane. And it may just be that this is the first sign of the lift in apartments coming on stream and curtailing price growth.
 
 
 
While the housing market is more mixed across the nation, it was encouraging to see some of the resource states seeing a decent lift in prices over November. And the lift in commodity prices may suggest that the mining towns may have come through the worst of the downturn.

  Overall policymakers will keep a close eye on the housing sector the early part of 2017, and will prefer to see more balanced house price growth across the nation. And in particular a lift in regional house prices would be a positive outcome. Annual growth in home prices across regional centres was just 1.4 per cent over the past 12 months. 

What do the figures show?

Private business investment

Overall: Business investment (spending on buildings and equipment) fell by 4 per cent in the September quarter after falling by 5.2 per cent in the June quarter. Spending on buildings fell by 5.7 per cent in the quarter while spending on equipment fell by 1.9 per cent. Investment is down 13.7 per cent over the year with buildings down by 24.3 per cent while equipment was up by 4.6 per cent.

Sectors: Mining investment fell by 7.2 per cent in the September quarter (ninth straight decline), while manufacturing spending fell by 4.9 per cent, spending by “other selected industries” fell by 1.9 per cent.

States: In seasonally adjusted terms investment fell in six of the eight states and territories in the September quarter. Investment fell the most in Western Australia (down 11.4 per cent), followed by Northern Territory (down 10 per cent), the ACT (down 8.1 per cent), South Australia (down 4.8 per cent), NSW (down 3.5 per cent), and Tasmania (down 0.1 per cent). The only rise was in Victoria (up 3.3 per cent) followed by Queensland (up 2.7 per cent).

Prices: The overall deflator for investment goods fell by 0.3 per cent in the September quarter after falling by 0.5 per cent in the June. The cost of buildings and structures rose by 0.2 per cent while the cost of equipment fell by 0.8 per cent. Over the year, the cost of investment goods fell by 0.5 per cent – the largest fall 41⁄2 years. The cost of buildings rose by 0.9 per cent while the cost of investment equipment fell by 3 per cent.

Forecasts: The fourth estimate for investment in 2015/16 is $106.9 billion, up 1.7 per cent on the third estimate but down 14.3 per cent over the year. Over the last six months, investment expectations have lifted by 17.1 percent.

Home prices

The CoreLogic Home Value Index of capital city home prices rose by 0.2 per cent in November and was up 9.3 per cent over the year.

In regional Australia, house prices fell by 0.2 per cent in October and were just 1.4 per cent higher than a year ago. (regional prices cover just houses and data is up to the end of October).

In capital cities, house prices rose by 0.2 per cent in November while apartment prices fell by 0.1 per cent. House prices were up 9.6 per cent on a year ago and apartments were up by 7.2 per cent.

The average Australian capital city house price (median price based on settled sales over quarter) was $645,000 and the average unit price was $540,000.
 
Dwelling prices rose in six of the eight capital cities in November: Darwin (up 3.7 per cent), followed by Adelaide (up 2.9 per cent), Hobart (up 0.9 per cent), Sydney (up 0.8 per cent), Perth (up 0.6 per cent), and Brisbane (up 0.4 per cent). Prices fell only in Melbourne (down 1.5 per cent). Dwelling prices in Canberra were unchanged.
 
Home prices were higher than a year ago in seven of the eight capital cities. Prices rose most in Sydney (up 13.1 per cent); followed by Melbourne (up 11.3 per cent), Hobart (up 8.5 per cent); Canberra (up 8.4 per cent); Adelaide (up 4.7 per cent), Brisbane (up 3.9 per cent) and Darwin (up 1.1 per cent). Prices fell in Perth (down by 3.4 per cent).

Total returns on capital city dwellings in the year to November rose by 13.1 per cent with houses up 13.3 per cent on a year earlier and units up 11.8 per cent.

Performance of Manufacturing

The Performance of Manufacturing index rose by 3.3 points to 54.2 in November. A reading above 50.0 indicates that the sector is expanding. The index had been above 50 for 13 months up until August 2016 – the longest period of expansion since September 2006.

AIG notes “The expansionary conditions were broad-based, with six of the seven sub-indexes in the Australian PMI indicating expansion in November. The strong lift in new orders (59.5 points) together with solid growth in sales (53.5 points) is promising.”

What is the importance of the economic data?

“Private New Capital Expenditure and Expected Expenditure” is released quarterly by the Bureau of Statistics. The figures show both actual and expected spending by businesses on tangible assets such as new buildings, machinery and office equipment. The figures are obtained after sampling 8,000 private business units.

The CoreLogic Hedonic Australian Home Value Index is based on Australia’s biggest property database. Unlike the ABS Index, which excludes terraces, semi-detached homes and apartments, the CoreLogic Hedonic Index includes all properties. Home prices are an important driver of wealth and spending.

The Australian Industry Group compiles the Performance of Manufacturing Index (PMI) each month. The Australian PMI is the Australian equivalent of the US ISM manufacturing gauge. The PMI is one of the timeliest economic indicators released in Australia. The PMI is useful not just in showing how the manufacturing sector is performing but in providing some sense about where it is heading. The key ‘forward looking’ components are orders and employment.

What are the implications for interest rates and investors?

The great unwinding of mining investment continues although the lift in commodity prices may result in more of a soft landing in coming quarters.
 
The Chinese economic data remains encouraging, showing that the transition from the industrial sector to household sector remains on track. The manufacturing sector is expanding, while the services sector is clearly the driver taking up any slack.
 
The latest Australian manufacturing data is encouraging, suggesting that the current levels of interest rates and the Australian dollar are working in favour of domestic producers.
 
The Reserve Bank has regularly noted that housing supply will lift over coming years as work is completed on the bevy of new homes – especially apartments. The Reserve Bank looks to be comfortably on the interest rate sidelines over the coming year. 
 
Savanth Sebastian is an economist for CommSec

Jonathan Chancellor

Jonathan Chancellor is one of Australia's most respected property journalists, having been at the top of the game since the early 1980s. Jonathan co-founded the property industry website Property Observer and has written for national and international publications.

Editor's Picks