Mining towns, for all their capital gains, are not worth the risk

Mining towns, for all their capital gains, are not worth the risk
Mining towns, for all their capital gains, are not worth the risk

It's no doubt hard work for real estate writers trying to think of something different to say several times per week. Last Thursday, Terry Ryder vented his spleen – again – about "lies and propaganda" from "vested interests" writing about property (vested interests being an unusual subject for an article signed off: Terry Ryder, founder of 

The other day he was fuming about talk of a property bubble, and the day before that the lies about housing shortages and then it was something else or other, can't remember what.

Last week it was me in the firing line after quoting an article about Sydney's middle sector of the market being "the only sector" of the property market to be at all-time highs – see last Friday's further article in Sydney Morning Herald and another one in Property Observer here.

Ryder notes that among other regional areas, Karratha, Dubbo, Mudgee and Whyalla have recently shown growth.

Look, fair enough – if you want to get bogged down in semantics, I'll admit I do not consider the town of Mudgee (population 10,000) to be a "sector" of the property market; I suppose you could feasibly term it a sub-sector, though. Truth be told, I couldn't even tell you exactly what prices have done in Mudgee, though some pretty good growth in 2012 springs to mind (just looked it up, and it recorded 9% growth).

I'm probably one of the very few people to have actually travelled to all of the listed places in the last couple of years, and all I say is, if you're comfortable in these days of elevated household leverage investing in small towns and remote regional markets, then, truly, go for it.

I wouldn't be. Having seen some the regional market bloodbaths in some overseas markets, I'm happy enough sticking with the boring capital cities approach.

APM reported last week that apartments in Sydney increased in median price by 5.6% last year, though obviously some sub-sectors of the market performed significantly better than others. Other capital cities such as Melbourne, Adelaide, Brisbane and Canberra were weak in 2012.

Prices of some quality properties in key suburbs of the inner-west of Sydney have grown by around a solid 25-35% over the past four  years or so. Again, I'm not talking about prices doubling overnight, just strong, steady growth. 

As anyone with even half a brain who invests in capital cities knows, it is preferable to aim to invest in the cities that have not experienced a recent boom, which is precisely why I picked out Sydney at that time ahead of other cities which had already shown strong growth.

So yes, since its spurt through to quarter one, 2004 price growth in Sydney has been lower than elsewhere, that's a given – but prices therefore haven't fallen from peaks in the same way as in other capital cities (hence "resilient") and I expect RP Data to report that strong growth has continued in Australia's largest capital through to January.

If you want to take the approach of carefully selecting time-frames for capital growth (or for that matter, individual suburbs like Canterbury), then pick any regional market you like from around Australia and note that prices are as cheap as chips as compared to quality city suburbs – that's due to poor long-term growth.  Almost as pointless an argument.

Personally, I invest in large and capital cities for the long term - the reasons for which I explained here with not much value in me reproducing – if you want to 'hotspot' (if that isn't unacceptable verbing of my adjectives) in Mount Isa, Wagga Wagga, the Pilbara or near wind farms off the coast of Tasmania, then, sincerely, best of luck to you.

The old regions versus capital cities debate has been well and truly done to death – you just have to take your viewpoint and go with it. I think the old phrase is: "let's agree to disagree".

Remember that property is best treated as a long-term investment, and long-term price growth ultimately has to be sourced from real and sustained wages growth. And also remember the concept of risk versus return. Let's just see wait and see what happens to regional markets in Australia the next time the economy shrinks.

Pete Wargent holds a range of finance and property qualifications and is the author of Get a Financial Grip – a simple plan for financial freedom.

Pete Wargent

Pete Wargent

Pete Wargent is the co-founder of, offering affordable homebuying assistance to all Australians, and a best-selling author and blogger.

Community Discussion

Be the first one to comment on this article
What would you like to say about this project?