The four pros and four cons of building a granny-flat

Alistair WalshDecember 7, 2020

Granny-flats have renewed interest given recent law changes in WA, but are they really a good idea for investors?

Here are the top four reasons for and against granny-flats:

For

Increase your property’s rental – adding a granny-flat can add a significant amount of rental income onto an investment property. It means you’ll get two income streams from a single lot.

Turn a negatively geared property into a positively geared property – This extra income can turn a negatively geared property into a positively geared one. It may mean you can stop claiming deductions but at least you’re earning some cash.

Many tenants prefer them to apartments – granny-flats allow tenants access to a back-yard, which means they’re often pet friendly and utilities are often included in the rent due to the complications of separate metering.

Always have an income from the property – If one tenant vacates then you’ll always have the other to see you through the vacant period. It’s not a lot of money but it keeps the cashflow going.

 

Against

Reduced rent on the main house – Tenants will demand a lower rent on the main house if they are forced to live with other tenants in their back yard.

Longer vacancy periods – Even with a reduced rent there is often a longer wait on finding tenants on a house with a granny-flat. Many people simple won’t do it due to concerns about neighbour disputes and loss of privacy.

It may not add value to the house – granny-flats can cost a lot to build – maybe in the vicinity of $100,000 but they don’t add that much to the house, if at all. Land and houses increase in value, but granny-flats don’t. And they’re not even that special any more in some suburbs, especially across Sydney that have had a surge in granny-flat activity. When it comes to resales granny-flats might reduce your buying interest to investors, with own occupiers taking their interest elsewhere.

They’re ugly – They’re not very pretty things to look at. There’s no getting round the fact that granny-flats detract from the outlook of the property, which could diminish it’s value.

Alistair Walsh

Deutsche Welle online reporter

Editor's Picks

Why the investment potential at Elevate Hume Place above Crows Nest Metro is proving too good to miss
Aria to move ahead with bulked-up 'Urban Forest' apartment development in South Brisbane
Surry Hills Village completes with just a handful of apartments remaining
Victoria & Albert's unique appeal to downsizers, holiday-makers and investors in the heart of Broadbeach
City Beat October 2024: Units fare better than houses in soft Melbourne property market