Converted churches as unconventional housing: He Said/She Said
Home buyers prepared to take a leap of faith in their pursuit of unconventional housing could find a converted church is the answer to their prayers. This Easter week our property contrarians, Jonathan Chancellor and Margie Blok, discuss recent sales and listings of blessed buildings.
Converting a church to a residence allows for enormous creative flair within a hallowed space ripe for residential resurrection - especially if it retains original ecclesiastical features including high vaulted ceilings, stained glass windows and timber arches. But they might need smart heating strategies.
One such property is the Bible Christian Church at 278 Gore Street, Fitzroy in Melbourne. The handsome circa 1860 building was sold for $3 million last October by Sydney shopping centre heiress, Betty Saunders-Klimenko, through Nelson Alexander Real Estate.
Bought by the Matear family, it is constructed of bluestone with tall brick-embellished Georgian windows and a wide Greek-Revival style façade added in 1911.
With vast living spaces and soaring ceilings, it has a splendidly proportioned dining area with a faded painted banner, proclaiming “Holiness Becomes Thy House”, which testifies to the building’s Provenance.
Converted 10 years ago into a three-bedroom, two-bathroom house with a six-car garage, the converted Fitzroy church was sold at a loss by Saunders-Klimenko who purchased the property for $3.41 million in June 2012. It previously traded at $684,000 in 2001, and at $15,500 in 1976. Earlier this month News Ltd papers reported Betty Saunders-Klimenko she was forced to take out a personal bank loan, of about $10 million, after spending a staggering $40 million on the motor racing team that had made her one of Australia’s most popular female sporting figures.
Also in Melbourne, an apartment in a former Wesleyan church at St Kilda sold for $1,175,000 two weeks ago through Hocking Stuart agent, Kehren Eade.
At the rear of the circa 1858 church in Fitzroy Street, the two-bedroom apartment incorporates the original church vestry which is converted to a splendid formal sitting room. It also features vaulted original timber ceilings, ornate cedar support beams and leadlight windows.
Situated in idyllic seaside surrounds, and directly opposite Albert Park Lake, the landmark bluestone church is the focal point of Alameda, a residential complex also incorporating a new modern apartment building.
Article continues on next page. Please click below.
At Parkerville near Perth in Western Australia, a lavish 35-hectare estate featuring a private chapel within its grounds, is for sale at $12.95 million through Cam Marron of Marron Real Estate.
Built by a previous owner of the property, the chapel has views across a pictureque lake set at the rear of a grand two-storey Georgian style mansion decorated with gold leaf, ornate plasterwork and six Waterford chandeliers.
Named Lilybrook, the property also features a tree-lined driveway, a guest cottage, a summer cabana and BBQ area, a swimming pool, floodlit tennis court, horse paddocks, stables, macadamia tree plantation, storage sheds and 650,000 litres of rainwater tanks.
At the other end of the price scale is a converted church in the tiny township of Muradup, situated 18 kilometres west of Kojonup (between Albany and Perth) in Western Australia.
For sale at $260,000 through Michael Scott of Ray White Crofts & Associates,
the circa 1957 double brick and tile church has been converted to a two-bedroom home with a large open-plan living area featuring original polished jarrah floors and stained glass windows.
Featuring its original signage, “Mary Help of Christians”, on the front wall adjacent to tall portico entrance, the air-conditioned church stands on a 2,848 square metre block (in Blackwood Road) with lawns, a vegetable garden and satellite dishes for internet and digital television.
One of the cheapest churches on the market is in the peaceful township of Dingee, situated about 50 kilometres from Bendigo in Victoria. For sale at $169,000 through Greg Fathers of Expert Real Estate, it stands on 8100 square metre block in Church Road.
Known as the Yallook church, the circa 1920s church building is ideal for use as a weekender. Substantially renovated into a residence, it has an attractive brick façade, a small vestry portico and original soaring ceilings with timber beams. Electric power is from a petrol generator and a small solar system, while the kitchen stove uses bottled gas. Outside are water tanks and a small garden shed.
Also in Victoria, historic St Andrews Church at Talbot is for sale at $385,000 through Julie Powell and Tash Martin at PRD Ballarat.
About one hour’s drive from Melbourne, Talbot is in the heart of the Victorian Goldfields, and at the edge of the Pyrenees wine region. From the property, it’s a 15 minute drive to the townships of Maryborough and Clunes, and 25 minutes drive to Avoca and its surrounding wineries.
Built 150 years ago as a Presbyterian church, the building has been converted into a residence with all the modern conveniences. Set on a 2140 square metre block landscaped with native plants and an outdoor eating area, the rendered double brick building has an insulated roof, a wood heater and overhead gas heating for winter warmth.
Operated as self-contained holiday accommodation, it has been reviewed in the The Age, Channel 7’s Coxy's Big Break, and Channel 9’s Postcards program.
Two minute’s stroll from the church are the town’s swimming pool, tennis courts, pub, restaurant/cafe and monthly farmers market.
Article continues on next page. Please click below.
In NSW, a rustic church at Dooralong, near Wyong on the Central Coast, is sale at $430,000 through Darin Butcher of Wiseberry Heritage.
One of the most iconic buildings in the Valley, this old rustic church has been converted into a tasteful two bedroom cottage with original features including leadlight windows.
Brimming with character, the heritage-listed timber building stands on a 2,000 square metres with lawns and a beautiful outlook.
Featuring wide outdoor deck, it has a large living area, timber country-style kitchen, a main bedroom (with an en-suite bathroom), a second bedroom and a main bathroom.
In the Kangaroo Valley, between Berry and the Southern Highlands in NSW, an 1889 church is for sale sale at more than $480,000 through Sandra Knight of Raine & Horne Berry.
On a 1288 square metre block in Moss Vale Road, the converted church stands on the side of a hill near the edge of the village and opposite Kangaroo Valley showground.
Remodelled in 1966, and recently converted to a stylish residence, it has two bedrooms, two bathrooms and an open-plan living room with a five-metre high ceiling, a stained glass window, a prayer cupboard and a pulpit incorporated into the kitchen.
Article continues on next page. Please click below.
HE SAID:
Churches converted to residences can look wonderful from the outside, but I really don’t think the interiors work well, especially if everything is put within the existing space. An extension is typically required. For someone like me who’s fond of standing on a soapbox, I especially find the adaptive reuse of the pulpit to be a problem.
Therefore, of the churches listed above, I’d choose the converted church in Kangaroo Valley (below) where the pulpit is cleverly merged with the kitchen island joinery, so I could stand at the bench and preach to my dinner guests.
SHE SAID:
For me, it’s the historic St Andrews Church at Talbot in the heart of the Victorian Goldfields, and close to the Pyrenees wine district. Not only do I think it would be a terrific weekender, but also I rather fancy the regular jaunts to Redbank Winery at Avoca to stock up on award winning Sally’s Paddock wines.
While stripped of its altar and pews, St Andrews (pictured below) is a converted church with tremendous character and beautiful original features including its windows and timber lined ceiling. The overhead gas heating for winter warmth also is a winner.